Perceived Risk: Petrol vs Electric Chainsaws…

In the realm of machinery safety, the concept of perceived risk plays a pivotal role in

shaping attitudes towards safety practices and compliance with regulations. As a

machinery safety consultant, it’s essential to recognize how individuals perceive risks

associated with different types of machinery. A prime example of this can be observed

in the contrasting perceptions of petrol and electric chainsaws.

Petrol Chainsaw: The Loud and Obvious Hazard

The distinct roar of a petrol chainsaw commands attention and instils a sense of

caution in those in proximity. Its loudness and appearance evoke a clear understanding of

the possible risk it presents. People tend to be more alert and conscientious when

approaching or using a petrol chainsaw, recognizing the inherent risks involved. The

audible cues of its operation serve as constant reminders of the potential hazards

present, even from a distance.

Additionally, the visible vibration from the engine of a petrol chainsaw reinforces the

awareness of its operational state and the potential for injury. This visibility makes it

easier for individuals to gauge the level of risk and take appropriate safety measures,

such as wearing personal protective equipment (PPE) and maintaining a safe distance.

Electric Chainsaw: Silent but Deceptive

In stark contrast, the electric chainsaw operates with a deceptive silence when the

chain is not in motion and is still quiet when the chain is in motion. This lack of audible

cues can create a false sense of security, as individuals may underrate the

potential hazards associated with its use. Unlike the petrol chainsaw, the presence of a

potential hazard is not immediately apparent to those nearby unless they witness the

machinery in operation.

Furthermore, distinguishing between a mains-powered electric chainsaw and a

battery-powered one adds another layer of complexity to risk perception. With

battery-powered models, the chainsaw can be easily started without any visible signs,

as the battery remains attached. This ambiguity increases the likelihood of accidents,

especially in environments where multiple chainsaws are present, and their power

sources are not clearly indicated.

Accessibility and Ease of Operation

Another factor influencing perceived risk is the accessibility and ease of operation of

electric chainsaws compared to petrol ones. Electric chainsaws are often perceived as

more user-friendly, making them accessible to individuals with little to no experience in

using such machinery. This accessibility, coupled with the deceptive silence of their

operation, can lead to complacency and a lack of vigilance regarding safety protocols.

Moreover, the prevalence of toy chainsaws resembling electric models further blurs the

lines between real and perceived risks, especially for children who may not fully grasp

the potential dangers associated with these tools.

Conclusion: Balancing Perception and Reality

In the realm of machinery safety, understanding and addressing perceived risks are

essential for promoting a culture of safety and compliance. While petrol and electric

chainsaws serve similar purposes, their distinct characteristics significantly influence

how individuals perceive and respond to potential hazards.

As machinery safety consultants, it’s crucial to educate stakeholders about the

importance of recognising and mitigating risks associated with different types of

machinery. By raising awareness and promoting proactive safety measures, we can

work towards minimizing accidents and ensuring the well-being of workers and the public.

Share this post

Let's work together

For a free initial consultation simply book an appointment via our meeting system by clicking below.

Eight (and a half) things that compliance and machinery safety consultants may not tell you... Knox Thomas

Eight (and a half) things that compliance and machinery safety consultants may not tell you…

Read more
8 Critical Safety Features

8 Machinery Safeguarding Functions You Need to be Compliant

Read more
Signing an EU Declaration of Conformity

Declarations of Conformity: Verify Before You Buy

Read more
A team making a risk assessment

How To Make A Risk Assessment

Read more

Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

*Indicates Required